- The Stoa Letter
- Posts
- How To Understand The Stoic Dichotomy Of Control
How To Understand The Stoic Dichotomy Of Control
Understanding what is up to you
Caleb Ontiveros
June 12, 2023
Welcome to The Stoa Letter, the newsletter on Stoic theory and practice.
Every week we share two emails to help you build resilience and virtue with ancient philosophy. Each email includes one meditation on Stoic theory, one action to do in order to become more Stoic, and links to the best resources we’ve found.
🏛️ Theory
The dichotomy of control is one of Stoicism’s most transformative ideas.
It’s simple: some things are up to you, others are not.
As Epictetus says in the opening of The Handbook:
There are some things that are up to us, others that are not up to us. The things up to us are understanding, impulse, desire, aversion and, in a word, whatever acts are ours. The things not up to us are the body, possessions, reputation, professional positions, and in a word, whatever acts are not ours.
But what is under your control?
In simplest terms, your judgments and decisions. That’s it. Throughout life, you are presented with sensations and impressions. These are questions that you answer with your choices. You decide whether to agree–or not–to each one.
The dichotomy of control calls for viewing our place in the world in a radically different way.
The Stoics called the things outside of our control externals or indifferents. It’s how we use indifferents that makes the difference.
Picture an excellent poker player. How the cards are dealt is external. She focuses on making strategic plays that will succeed over thousands of games. Fortune is fickle. She knows that she may make the best decisions and still lose a single hand. The outcome of each game is indifferent. Anyone can get lucky and “win” off of poor choices. That’s not what makes a great player.
Stoics don’t bind themselves to externals. To the extent that we can, we desire to be excellent in whatever role we occupy. We harmonize our choices with the tragedy and comedy of the world the best that we can. We desire to do our best with “whatever acts are ours” and willingly embrace everything else.
As Marcus Aurelius reminds himself:
Willingly give yourself to Fate, allowing her to spin her thread into whatever things she pleases.
🎯 Action
Do your best with “whatever acts are yours.” Make the best choices and judgments you can.
🎉 Stoa Summer Offer
We’re running a special for the Stoa app. Get our annual subscription for only $49.99 USD. 29% off! Subscribe for less than $5 a month for hundreds of lessons, meditations, and Stoic routines.
Joins thousands of other Stoics using Stoa to become more resilient and virtuous.
Available only in June.
The offer is only valid if you do not currently have an annual subscription.
🔗 Links
💡 Here's another framing that many have found powerful: the dichotomy of control describes what you are. Ultimately, we are choice-making beings. We are not what happens to us, but what we agree to and decide to do.
📔 Read Stoa cofounder Michael Tremblay's piece What Many People Misunderstand about the Stoic Dichotomy of Control. It focuses on the idea of identity instead of control.
📖 William Stephens and Scott Aikin’s translation of Epictetus is useful: Epictetus’s 'Encheiridion': A New Translation and Guide to Stoic Ethics. It includes clear and crisp commentary.
🎧️ Listen to this topical episode Stoicism FAQ: Who Should You Read First? What Is Up to You? for more discussion on the common question.
📓 Find a stricter translation of the Marcus Aurelius quote here. The only difference – he references a specific Fate of ancient Greek myth, Clotho.
What did you think about today's letter? |
🏆️ Share The Stoa Letter
If you find what we’re doing useful, please share it. Just have people sign up with your link below.
1 Referral — Cheatsheet on The Most Important Stoic Concepts— get access to our list of the most important Stoic concepts with links and instructions for putting each into practice.
3 Referrals – The Stoic Training Program PDF — in this 10-page guide, we share the three main ideas and practices that ground a Stoic approach to life.
5 Referrals – Five Stoic Meditations – get five downloadable meditations to go deeper into your practice.
Reply